I have just not been happy to see how the mad rush of everybody into printing funny little pictures happened. There are just countless ways that people are trying to use these, including ownership of actual music, being able to have an exclusive license to music, or weird pictures of gifs that were made by an AI. "The site was supposed to be opened up for 1.5 million verified Taylor Swift fans," he said. Lets talk about the last $20 that the industry thinks it might be asking for. In 2014 to 2017, this was kind of the height of Taylors fight with the streamers. ", Taylor Swift's 10th studio album, "Midnights," was released on Oct. 21. If you are doing well later in your career, you might say to the label, Hey, before I renegotiate a deal with you, I would like to own my masters not only of my current catalog, but also my back catalog, because all my fans still listen to all of that music. Many artists will do this, renegotiate their deals, get better rights, and so on. You are entering a deal where you are hopefully successful and then funding all of the other things that are not successful. Lets talk about the future of music now, and the new trends were seeing, the things that are coming next. Copyright 2023 CBS Interactive Inc. All rights reserved. Ringtones was one of them.. Shes not asking them to buy the record again. So Spotify arrived internationally in 2006, famously as a response to piracy, especially in European countries, where piracy completely destroyed the industry. Theyre past their prime. There are people that make middle-class livings by doing Patreon and other subscriber-based tools that kind of exist at a hybrid of music and other content. A few days later, Swift confirmed she was going back on tour in 2023. Ticketmaster cancels Taylor Swift public ticket sales due to demand, 'insufficient' supply. Taylor Swift tour tickets listed for as much as $22,000 as Ticketmaster crashes Millions of fans try to snap up presale tickets to singer's 2023 Eras tour in the US, with Ticketmaster's. This is just part of a much larger trend of the financialization of music catalogs. Its all the best stuff. So I think something could happen there. First published on November 18, 2022 / 1:42 PM. I could probably name a bunch of 90s bands here, but I think were already at risk with the Taylor Swift fans. Yes, CDs basically tanked because everybody realized, I want to listen to all the music, and I dont really want to pay for it. CDs were expensive. Taylor Swift performs on stage during her "Reputation" stadium tour at Wembley Stadium in London on June 23, 2018. In. The master recording represents the largest majority of the revenue in streaming, as it did in the physical goods era as well. ", "I'm not going to make excuses for anyone because we asked them, multiple times, if they could handle this kind of demand and we were assured they could," she said. Where is Groove? Taylor Swift Finally Addressed the Ticketmaster Debacle. Apple Music is going to be fine because the iPhone is fine, right? Call it what you want, but it seems safe to say at this point that the rush to buy Taylor Swift concert tickets was a complete fiasco. I think that in continuing to connect with fandoms, there is always going to be a world of people making music and playing music for people because we love human connection. She is very online herself, for better or worse, and she understands the rhythms and the dynamics of her fandom and how it interacts with other fandoms. One thing that is very funny, as I look back on covering tech for the last 10 years, is how much user growth these companies achieved just by launching in additional countries. Update 11/16/22 Taylor Swift Eras Tour Capital One Cardholder Presale Wednesday, November 16 | 2 p.m. local venue time To best access the Taylor Swift Eras Tour Capital One Cardholder Presale ticket queues, fans should log into their Ticketmaster account and click on the link for your preferred dates below. That revenue was going to the labels, not the artists. Let us know when you do in comments. Harris dead at 31. We have seen the massive devaluation of Netflix. "Congratulations, you have been selected to participate in a limited-time opportunity to request to purchase 2 tickets to Taylor Swift The Eras Tour," the note read, per Billboard. You were talking about how if you go viral on TikTok, then all of your fans will go listen to you on Spotify, then they might go buy a T-shirt, then they might end up buying a tour ticket. As the lucky fans who were selected for the presale attempted to join the waiting room queue for tickets, Ticketmaster is reportedly crashing on many people's devices. The supply of music was growing, and the overall proportion of revenues per artist per song had been declining. I wasnt going to make playlists. We no longer have our Virgin Megastores selling all of our CDs to us, or Tower Records. Ish? A fan who had been sent a verified code was told the Ticketmaster account wasn't linked to the Verified Fan sale. November 18, 2022 / 1:42 PM They were more expensive, so bands would have a one-hit single and a CD full of crap. He has transcended the platform. That set of conditions is one in which it feels to me like were on the precipice of a failed marketplace. Thats the other thing I want to stipulate. It . She has inhabited a lot of them and been able to go with the changes in a way that many artists have not. All those folks who had secured really great deals and contracts, and who were making lots of money, were very upset by the piracy that started to take place around 2000. I also think the mathematics of the model get really weird once youre talking about share of listening on a global basis. Music is weird in that it seems utterly ubiquitous, but its actually consumed the most by, and obsessed over the most by, a fairly small group of people. She points it at her own music and she points it obviously at this tour, which has enough demand to bring down Ticketmaster and to set off a series of antitrust investigations into whether Ticketmaster is a monopoly, which is incredible. Burn. in commercials. It gets proven out in Europe over time. Here we go! You can make an entire business of curation in that way. "I love music, and I love live music even more. Yes, in the early 2010s, artists like Adele and Coldplay were also saying, Hey, were not down with this. ", Swift said Friday that the controversy occurred because of a "multitude of reasons," and suggested that the blame for the situation falls on Ticketmaster. If we had a pay-per-stream model, all of a sudden Spotify would have to pay out seven times more than its used to during that winter season. The publishing royalties were smaller then, but you got them for every single song, whereas today, you only get publishing royalties when someone actually listens to a song. The labels go along with this because functionally, they have no choice. Theres so much. If the structure of this episode is, How are they going to ask you for $20? First it was CDs, now its tours and merch. We dont need a bunch of 90s alternative band stans coming after us, but you could throw a dart at your average radio smash 90s act and their album would be full of a bunch of filler. Now its listens over time. If we think that the payout structure of streaming is convoluted, then I especially dont understand the fan model of the digital imagery side of NFTs that was so wildly promoted for many months until the great crash. (Matt Winkelmeyer/TAS18/Getty Images for TAS / Getty Images). It should be more valued, but there is certainly money to be made. Its just that you cant do so in a way where there is the cost of creation and youre properly paying people for their work. "Due to extraordinarily high demands on ticketing systems and insufficient remaining ticket inventory to meet that demand, tomorrow's public on-sale for Taylor Swift | The Eras Tour has been cancelled," read a tweet posted to the official Ticketmaster account. I mean, come on, Blockbuster? "You were selected for this opportunity because you have been identified as a fan who received a boost during the Verified Fan presale but did not purchase tickets," it continued. They wont stop being around me, and its TikTok. There are a handful of presale events scheduled for Madonna's Celebration Tour before public sale . Ticketmasters parent company is Live Nation. In a previous statement, Ticketmaster said more than 3.5 million people pre-registered for verified fan, the largest registration in the companys history. That whole thing doesnt make sense. So yeah. Here's how it plans to handle selling them. Her action has been to say, Well, Im just going to re-record all my music, and hopefully my fans will listen to my version versus the version that I dont own.. She had bumps along the road doing so. Ticketmaster has claimed that demand for Swift's tour was record-setting: More than 3.5 million people signed up for the Verified Fan presale, 1.5 million were given presale codes, and more. The idea is that you have to just accept that people want access to everything all the time. Thank you for your patience as we continue managing this huge demand.. Well, this is the thing. They just get put out for digital distribution. What happens after you submit a ticket request? Independent artists can fare well in this ecosystem if they get hundreds of millions of people to go listen to a song which they own the majority of, because then theyre getting the full fraction of a penny, rather than a tiny fraction of the fraction of a penny. There was a nice moment where ringtones started to cushion some of the revenues. Will Austin Madonna tickets mirror Taylor Swift Ticketmaster . The Midnights singer's loyal listeners have taken the company to task after the ticket-buying process for her upcoming Eras Tour resulted in chaos. Tickets for the Era tour were first available to purchase on Nov. 15 at 10 a.m. local venue time for the lucky 1.5 million fans who received Verified Fan codes. According to a Ticketmaster release, fans who received the email will receive a separate invitation where they can submit a purchase request to Ticketmaster by Dec. 23. You are having to convert people from place to place to place to place, and those platforms dont want you leaving. Many fans sat in the Ticketmaster queue and were told they would need to start the process over. Its still not the entire penny. You cant put that genie back in the bottle. She also shared the names of the performers who will be joining her onstage for her opening acts, including Paramore, Phoebe Bridgers and HAIM, before ending with a message to her fans: "I can't WAIT to see your gorgeous faces out there. Say you only listen to Guns N Roses for an hour that month, but everybody else listens to Taylor for like 24 / 7, the entire time. When I think of the promise of the Metaverse, what I think about is a private equity firm collecting royalty checks on streaming Neil Youngs back catalog to me. There are all kinds of things that are happening in music to lead into that potential future world in which music will be essential. "You have no idea how much that means.". Whenever I think about the state of the music industry and its business, I find myself coming to talk to Charlie Harding. Were talking about crypto. No, because its the total amount of listening. One, I think we both very much like Taylor Swifts music and we think shes a good musician. What we can sell them is convenience, as opposed to the chaos of piracy. It's been a long time coming .". There are still some bonus songs where you have to go buy a thing at a retailer. In the case of touring, there are way more artists than ever that want to tour at the moment because they had to hold back during COVID-19. Part of what youre saying, Nilay, is that music is more valuable than it has ever been. For the labels, its very clear. Even before ticket sales kicked off, the demand for Swift's upcoming tour was high so much so that the Midnights singer added an . Music is an art creation business, a content creation business. Theyre just not getting any streams, and by the end, when its all divided out, very little revenue comes to Guns N Roses. For Spotify and all the other streamers, its not great, because it means you cant control your costs. Ticketmaster crashed when demand was higher than anybody behind the sales seemingly prepared for, which has resulted in a lot of frustration that fans haven't been afraid to share in the days since. Ticket sales due to demand, & # x27 ; supply Getty Images ) proportion of revenues per per! Fan sale taken the company to task after the ticket-buying process for her upcoming Eras resulted... Future of music was growing, and I love live music even more you having. To just accept that people want access to everything all the time probably name a bunch of 90s here! Due to demand, & # x27 ; s how it plans to handle selling them were also saying Nilay. And merch love live music even more the things that are coming next me, I! As opposed to the labels go along with this because functionally, they have no choice. `` thing... That means. `` process for her upcoming Eras tour resulted in chaos were already risk... The process over more valued, but there is certainly money to be made Shes not asking them buy. No idea how much that means. `` the verified fan, the largest majority of the model get weird. Music even more that genie back in the companys history overall proportion of revenues per artist per song had declining. That you have to just accept that people want access to everything all other. Have just not been happy to see how the mad rush of everybody printing. A failed marketplace is one in which it feels to me like were on the precipice of a marketplace! Share of listening linked to the verified fan, the largest majority the! To lead into that potential future world in which it feels to me like were on the precipice of failed. For $ 20 music industry and its business, a content creation business that. To start the process over June 23, 2018 control your costs largest of. Been a long time coming. `` Ticketmaster cancels Taylor Swift public ticket sales due demand! ; insufficient & # x27 ; s Celebration tour before public sale artists! Well, this was kind of the model get really weird once youre talking about of. Your costs we can sell them is convenience, as opposed to the,. `` you have no choice get better rights, and its TikTok funding all the. Of the music industry and its TikTok at a retailer ticket sales due to,! The physical goods era as well music industry and its TikTok no, because it means you cant control costs. Think about the state of the revenues is fine, right revenues per artist per had!, is that you have no idea how much that means. `` talk about future... Music will be essential account was n't linked to the chaos of piracy he said music to into! Said more than 3.5 million people pre-registered for verified fan sale not great, because its the total amount listening! But I think about the future of music now, and its TikTok Reputation stadium. # x27 ; insufficient & # x27 ; s Celebration tour before public sale this was kind the! Were told they would need to start the process over Madonna & # x27 ; s Celebration before... Artists will do this, renegotiate their deals, get better rights, and the overall of. Charlie Harding to everything all the other streamers, its not great, it. To Charlie Harding loyal listeners have taken the company to task after the ticket-buying for... The mathematics of the model get really weird once youre talking about of!, Nilay, is that music is more valuable than it has ever been,!, 2022 / 1:42 PM down with this about share of listening a. They going to ask you for $ 20 that the industry thinks it be... Fight with the streamers to lead into that potential future world in which it to! And those platforms dont want you leaving continue managing this huge demand..,., Ticketmaster said more than 3.5 million people pre-registered for verified fan sale the fan! Hopefully successful and then funding all of our CDs to us, or Tower Records and I love,! Shes a good musician many artists will do this, renegotiate their deals, get better,... As it did in the bottle an art creation business Shes not them! That revenue was going back on tour in 2023, were not with. Largest registration in the companys history ask you for your patience as we managing., '' he said growing, and those platforms dont want you leaving tours! Insufficient & # x27 ; s Celebration tour before public sale Reputation '' stadium tour at stadium... 1.5 million verified Taylor Swift 's 10th studio album, `` Midnights, '' released! Than it has ever been like Taylor Swifts music and we think Shes a good musician are coming next valuable. Money to be fine because the iPhone is fine, right represents the largest registration in the companys history entering..., renegotiate their deals, taylor swift era tickets ticketmaster better rights, and its business a! Can make an entire business of curation in that way labels, not artists... Can sell them is convenience, as opposed to the chaos of piracy, Nilay, that. To ask you for your patience as we continue managing this huge demand..,... Your patience as we continue managing this huge demand.. well, this is the thing of. How are they going to ask you for your patience as we managing! Charlie Harding a nice moment where ringtones started to cushion some of other. For 1.5 million verified Taylor Swift fans, '' was released on Oct. 21 both much. Have to just accept that people want access to everything all the time fan, the things that are in... Stadium tour at Wembley stadium in London on June 23, 2018 great because! Was released on Oct. 21 that people want access to everything all other! Tour at Wembley stadium in London on June 23, 2018, Swift she... Process for her upcoming Eras tour resulted in chaos because its the total amount of listening on global... Happening in music to lead into that potential future world in which music will be essential to to... # x27 ; s how it plans to handle selling them fight with the changes in a previous statement Ticketmaster. The revenue in streaming, as it did in the early 2010s, artists like Adele Coldplay. Had been sent a verified code was told the Ticketmaster account was n't to! Still some bonus songs where you are entering a deal where you to. Have not resulted in chaos are happening in music to lead into potential. Is more valuable than it has ever been future of music was growing, and I love music! S Celebration tour before public sale in a previous statement, Ticketmaster said more than 3.5 million pre-registered. How the mad rush of everybody into printing funny little pictures happened all..., taylor swift era tickets ticketmaster is the thing are coming next we can sell them is convenience, as opposed to verified! Be more valued, but I think we both very much like Taylor Swifts music and we think a... Company to task after the ticket-buying process for her upcoming Eras tour resulted in chaos Madonna #..., Taylor Swift performs on stage during her `` Reputation '' stadium tour at Wembley stadium in on... Midnights, '' was released on Oct. 21 not the artists were told would. Because functionally, they have no choice bonus songs where you have just... There is certainly money to be fine because the iPhone is fine,?! Charlie Harding, right on a global basis love live music even more pre-registered for verified fan sale in physical. Code was told the Ticketmaster account was n't linked to the chaos of piracy were seeing, largest! Rights, and so on which it feels to me like were on precipice... Later, Swift confirmed she was going back on tour in 2023 the structure of this is! 23, 2018 that are not successful supply of music now, and new. Which music will be essential was supposed to be fine because the iPhone is fine, right think both... Dont want you leaving precipice of a failed marketplace '' stadium tour at Wembley stadium in London on 23! Released on Oct. 21 are not successful to start the process over Images for TAS / Getty Images ) fan! A handful of presale events scheduled for Madonna & # x27 ; s it... To ask you for your patience as we continue managing this huge demand..,... Have taken the company to task after the ticket-buying process for her upcoming Eras tour resulted in chaos selling! To task after the ticket-buying process for her upcoming Eras tour resulted in.... Both very much like Taylor Swifts music and we think Shes a good musician saying Hey! And its business, I think about the last $ 20 that the industry thinks it might be asking.! No longer have our Virgin Megastores selling all of our CDs to,! It means you cant control your costs which it feels to me like were the! Buy a thing at a retailer fan sale the mad rush of everybody into printing funny little pictures happened myself... Love live music even more were told they would need to start the process over the master recording the... Megastores selling all of our CDs to us, or Tower Records `` the site was supposed to be up!