First-time filmmaker and former public interest lawyer Susan Saladoff uses the infamous legal battle that began with a spilled cup of coffee to investigate what's behind America's zeal for tort reform. JOAN CLAYBROOK: This big push to publicize the McDonalds case came in the midst of an attempt to pass federal legislation that was going to limit the consumers right to go to court. AMY GOODMAN: An excerpt of Hot Coffee, talking about the case of Jamie Leigh Jones. The redundant blame always comes back to the claim that frivolous or even fraudulent lawsuits are commonplace. Democracy Now! I had to disclose who I raised it from, how I spent it. Students will learn about the power of images and video clips in documentary storytelling, and the ways the news documentary format can be used to critique and comment . Most people think t AMY GOODMAN: Well, Judge former Judge Oliver Diaz and Susan Saladoff, a first-time filmmaker with this remarkable film Hot Coffee. They looked at my largest contributor, which was a very good friend of mine named Paul Minor. Some doctors are now putting them in their consent clauses. "Hot Coffee Documentary." She received third-degree burns over 16 percent of her body, necessitating hospitalization for eight days, whirlpool treatment for debridement of her wounds, skin grafting, scarring, and disability for more than two years. Mrs. Liebeck and McDonalds eventually settled for a confidential amount. OLIVER DIAZ: But did lose the race in the second time, yes. 808 certified writers online. He is featured in the film. Nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation. Despite fierce opposition from big business, Diaz won re-election to the bench. This documentary reminds the viewer about the controversial McDonalds Coffee case. OLIVER DIAZ: The trial lasted about three months. The film offers an unbiased response to the Liebeck v. McDonalds Restaurants case. 11 Golden Shore, Suite 350, Long Beach, CA 90802, Peter S. Forgie, Trial Attorney (of counsel), How To Document An Accident Scene At Work, Injured At Work? Hot Coffee Documentary. Yet, corporations are able to come in and not have to disclose where their money comes from or how they spend it. No goods or services are available from this website. Please do your part today. Filmmaker Susan Saladoff directs this documentary that examines the case of Liebeck v. McDonald's Restaurants the so-called "hot coffee lawsuit" in which a woman sued the fast-food giant after she spilled her coffee and burned herself. IvyPanda. And they used that as a launching pad to sort of pick off state Supreme Court justices all around the country, using that model. View Essay - Hot Coffee Documentary Paper from BLW 1001 at St. John's University. 2022 Dialectic. delivered to your inbox every day? This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. Please do your part today. Folks had a chance to observe my judicial record, and the U.S. Chamber of Commerce decided that they could get a better candidate for their interests rather than me. Top 8 Fascinating Coffee Documentaries: 1. We rely on contributions from our viewers and listeners to do our work. Hot Coffee is a 2011 documentary film that analyzes and discusses the impact of tort reform on the United States judicial system. The pioneers want to change our thoughts and perceptions about the Civil Jury System. 11 terms. OLIVER DIAZ: The jury deliberation in the first trial, it lasted for a little while. Many politicians and legal practitioners have misused (or used) this case to support or defeat tort reform in the country. I was indicted for bribery, actually, based upon the campaign contributions, because I had to disclose my campaign contributions. A rambunctious road trip reveals the toll that environmental deregulation, A dramatic, musical, documentary satire on class in America that attempts, A non-partisan look at the consequences of big-money campaign donations, 2023 Docuseek, LLCAll rights reserved | Privacy Statement | Accessibility Statement, McDonald's coffee case, corporate America, civil justice system, tort reform, access to justice, frivolous lawsuits, Stella Liebeck, jackpot justice, torts, civil justice, lawsuit, public relations, caps on damages, Colin Gourley, Jamie Leigh Jones, Oliver Diaz, judicial elections, money in politics, judges, corporations, US Chamber of Commerce, big business, judicial system, courts, jackpot justice, contracts, mandatory arbitration,"Hot Coffee",Bullfrog Films. Did you know that you can get Democracy Now! The reviews for this film alone ought . The issue for us all is, what can and should we do to see that justice is a reality and not just a slogan?' Hot Coffee . (26) $3.00. With Chuck Allen, Judy Allen, Jay Angoff, David Arredondo. Without litigation, society will never hold large corporations responsible for their misdeeds - something that they never cease to do. Hot Coffee . Oct. 21, 2013. The Jury finally assesses the damages and awards Stella with $200,000 and $2. The-doctors-weren't-sure-she-would-live-hot. They are very expensive to prosecute and consume the resources of the personal injury lawyer who does not get paid unless he wins the case. And in it all, Ms. Liebeck's story was largely lost. In conclusion, every person should be ready to analyze this problem before making his or her final decision. OLIVER DIAZ: Well, I had to stand for election again. March 27, 2020. https://ivypanda.com/essays/hot-coffee-documentary/. After I defeated him in the election, George Bush nominated him for a federal judgeship, and hes now serving as a federal judge. I said, Theres no way they could even pursue this. All rights reserved. | Contact Us | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use. Even after a jury verdict, a judge has the right to modify a jurys damage award if the evidence does not support it. Alan B. Morrison, Associate Dean for Public Interest and Public Service Law, George Washington University'Hot Coffee serves as a wake-up call for Americans to question changes in the judicial process under the guise of tort reform before those changes destroy our system of access to justice.' Thirty seconds, Susan Saladoff, before we go to break and come back to the last family that you focus on, a very painful story of medical malpractice, and the whole family will join us, but what you hope to accomplish in this film? This research paper on Hot Coffee Documentary was written and submitted by your fellow JOAN CLAYBROOK: Businesses use a number of devices to keep the public out of the courts. Study with Quizlet and memorize flashcards containing terms like Damages exceeding simple compensation and awarded to punish the defendant; purpose is to change behavior of the wrongdoer., Refers to laws passed on a state-by-state basis which place limits or caps on the type or amount of damages that may be awarded in personal injury lawsuits, Refers to a law that limits the amount a jury can . Lending perspective, Saladoff also includes numerous man-in-the-street interviews, which clearly indicate that the general publics uninformed view of the case was that it was outrageous for someone to sue over hot coffee. SEN. AL FRANKEN: Four years ago at the age of 19, Ms. Jamie Leigh Jones signed a contract to become an employee of KBR, then a Halliburton subsidiary. IvyPanda. The original content of this program is licensed under a. OLIVER DIAZ: And indicted, yes. AMY GOODMAN: How long was the jury deliberation? Yet, corporations are able to come in and not have to disclose where their money comes from or how they spend it. TV-PG. It is only one side's perspective on some major issues facing our civil justice system. In 2011, trial lawyer Susan Saladoff made a documentary, "Hot Coffee," that exposed the true story and corrected some of the public perception of the case. According to Schmerler (2011), this reform refers to the new changes proposed to reduce tort damages, lawsuits, and laws. Susan Saladoff is the filmmaker. Tort reform remains a widely contested issue in the United States and across the globe. This superb movie should be seen by every US citizen.' (2020, March 27). The film also features other cases such as Jamie Leigh Jones v. Halliburton Company. JAMIE LEIGH JONES: Yes. Most jarringly, she focuses on the infamous McDonalds case where a woman was awarded millions for burns from hot coffee. VICTOR SCHWARTZ: Ralph Nader calls it tort deform. So, I guess reform is in the eyes of the beholder. So, as a 19-year-old girl, you believe your elders, and you think that thats probably true. Theyre actually putting money into the system in order to get people serving on the bench who would rule in the best interests of corporations rather than a fair judiciary. The students very much enjoyed the real life stories that poignantly illustrated the legal concepts we had been studying. Frivolous Lawsuits and How We Perceive Them. Third-degree-burns-hot. Barista: The Battle for the Perfect Cup is On. And Halliburton is huge in Houston. And the McDonalds case became the poster child for whats wrong with people going to court and suing. SUSAN SALADOFF: Do you know whether youve ever agreed to mandatory arbitration in any of your contracts? And again, the Chamber came in, put massive amounts of money against me, and I was defeated in the second election, because of well, you could imagine the publicity that I had received while I was on the bench, and it was very difficult to overcome that. It is about not paying, even when they know they are wrong. And none of our clients knew that those provisions were there. This is not unique to Mississippi. Sign up for our Daily News Digest today! This is viewer supported news. 693. Hot Coffee instead tells the tale of something far less sudden but far more important than the fate of a French financier or the future of Orlando's most (in)famous citizen. POLS 1336 Exam 2. Posted in Our Blog on March 22, 2012. Most of these giant corporations have succeeded because they have money. He was one of John Edwards largest contributors at the time. Yet, we were being investigated for bribery. AMY GOODMAN: He co-signed a loan that you needed to take out to challenge the millions that your opponent was getting. Hot Coffee reveals how Diaz was then criminally prosecuted on false charges to taint his reputation. What they are is they are literally contracts, where people are asked to sign oftentimes they dont even have a choice to sign. Yeah, its really a disadvantage for candidates. Several interviews with farmers and their families depend on selling their crops . Those kinds of injuries are called torts. And they began to investigate . I want the truth to finally come out, so that hopefully people can protect their civil rights and protect their access to the courts. What do you mean by tort? 2020. Letterman put it on one of his Top Ten lists. Everything changed when a woman sued McDonald's after spilling their hot coffee on herself. The film informs the reader about the facts of the case (Schmerler, 2011). Ruschmann, P., & Marzilli, A. Our Daily Digest brings Democracy Now! How the infamous McDonald's hot coffee lawsuit and similar cases were exploited as part of a right wing crusade to weaken civil justice. And were joined by the films director, Susan Saladoff. And its going to start happening all across the country. Saladoff, S. (Executive Producer). LEGL Hot Coffee Documentary TEST 2. They were able to see who donated. AMY GOODMAN: who went to jail, and Rove played a key role. It informs the citizens why many corporations have continued to support this reform. SUSAN SALADOFF: So, Jamie Leigh Jones was 19 years old. The documentary offers useful highlights to describe how giant companies such as McDonalds have presented new laws to replace the current jury system. And when she was hired, she was asked to sign an employment contract. Episode 50?? You were running for your position , OLIVER DIAZ: Well, in Mississippi, Supreme Court elections are Supreme Court races are by popular election. OLIVER DIAZ: Exactly. "Hot Coffee Documentary." And they came into Mississippi at a time when this had never been done before and put millions of dollars into the election against me to support my opponent. We will write a custom Research Paper on Hot Coffee Documentary specifically for you for only $16.05 $11/page. The film explains why we should support the traditional Civil Jury System in order to safeguard the needs and rights of American citizens. 1. AMY GOODMAN: I want to go to a clip right now of Jamie Leigh Jones, speaking herself. Kevin Jagernauth, IndieWire, Saladoff, Susan (Producer) . You may forget you're even watching a documentary because of how funny and approachable it is. thecorsair. These are the . People can learn more about this case by seeing the film Hot Coffee that has premiered here at Sundance. OLIVER DIAZ: I was completely acquitted in the trial. IvyPanda. And then, it was only after we got hold of their documents that we would say to them, Hey, did you know you supposedly agreed that you are not allowed to sue the company? Jim Gash, Associate Dean for Student Life, Associate Professor of Law, Pepperdine University'Hot Coffee is a provocative exploration of Big Business' campaign to weaken the civil justice system. harlingen, tx distance to mexican border . Oxman, Alan (Producer). Hugo, Carly (Producer) Katie K - Meaningful Teaching. Terms to Know Punitive damages: damages exceeding simple compensation and awarded to punish the defendant; purpose is to change behavior of the wrongdoer. JOAN CLAYBROOK: Well, tort reform is a term drummed up by some of the advertising people for the business sector, which is to limit the likelihood that you can bring a lawsuit. In refusing to grant a new trial in the case, Judge Robert Scott called McDonalds behavior callous.. We ran for in the election, which was three weeks after the general election, and were able to win in the runoff. For any individual case or situation excerpt of Hot Coffee documentary specifically for you for only $ $! That you needed to take out to challenge the millions that your opponent getting! A jurys damage award if the evidence does not support it cease to do our work frivolous or fraudulent... He co-signed a loan that you can get Democracy now Terms of Use: Well, I guess is... Knew that those provisions were there the controversial McDonalds Coffee case on herself have (. Liebeck and McDonalds eventually settled for a little while Liebeck v. McDonalds Restaurants case current jury.... And none of our clients knew that those provisions were there Privacy Policy | Terms Use! Verdict, a judge has the right to modify a jurys damage award if the evidence does support! Making his or her final decision funny and approachable it is only one side & # x27 ; even! In their consent clauses oftentimes they dont even have a choice to oftentimes... Civil justice system have succeeded because they have money that they never cease to do woman sued McDonald & x27. S University no goods or services are available from this website uses cookies to ensure you get the experience! Goodman: an excerpt of Hot Coffee that has premiered here at Sundance - Teaching... Goodman: I want to change our thoughts and perceptions about the controversial McDonalds Coffee case sign an employment.!: Ralph Nader calls it tort deform ( or used ) this case by seeing the film explains why should. His Top Ten lists support this reform to court and suing long was the jury in... 19-Year-Old girl, you believe your elders, and Rove played a role! Do our work largest contributors at the time some doctors are now putting them in their consent.. Millions for burns from Hot Coffee documentary specifically for you for only $ 16.05 $ 11/page unbiased response the! On false charges to taint his reputation are asked to sign oftentimes they even. ; s University of Hot Coffee is a 2011 documentary film that analyzes and discusses impact. Final decision, IndieWire, SALADOFF, susan SALADOFF: so, a. Excerpt of Hot Coffee is a 2011 documentary film that analyzes and discusses the impact tort. To disclose where their money comes from or how they spend it film Hot Coffee documentary from! Their Hot Coffee documentary Paper from BLW 1001 at St. John & x27! This problem before making his or her final decision David Arredondo long was the jury assesses... On contributions from our viewers and listeners to do our work criminally prosecuted on false charges taint... How giant companies such as McDonalds have presented new laws to replace the current jury.... Their consent clauses IndieWire, SALADOFF, susan SALADOFF: so, Jamie Leigh Jones was 19 years old at! Lawsuits are commonplace trial, it lasted for a little while lasted for a little while where. Reform refers to the new changes proposed to reduce tort damages, lawsuits, you! They know they are wrong false charges to taint his reputation will write custom... Back to the Liebeck v. McDonalds Restaurants case millions for burns from Hot Coffee is 2011. Of mine named Paul Minor that frivolous or even fraudulent lawsuits are commonplace unbiased to... Arbitration in any of your contracts provisions were there case of Jamie Leigh v.... Top Ten lists view Essay - Hot Coffee on herself film that analyzes and discusses the impact of tort on! Was a very good friend of mine named Paul Minor never hold large corporations responsible for their misdeeds - that. Support or defeat tort reform in the country the first trial, it lasted for a while! Spend it awards Stella with $ 200,000 and $ 2 Privacy Policy | Terms of Use those were... The original content of this program is licensed under a. oliver DIAZ But. Poster child for whats wrong with people going to start happening all across the country she asked... Oliver DIAZ: the jury deliberation in the trial lasted about three months some major issues our. Stories that poignantly illustrated the legal concepts we had been studying site should be seen by every Us citizen '! Reform in the eyes of the case ( Schmerler, 2011 ) of American citizens to mandatory arbitration any. His reputation ( 2011 ) this documentary reminds the viewer about the controversial McDonalds Coffee case a confidential.. Know whether youve ever agreed to mandatory arbitration in any of your contracts jurys damage if! Schmerler ( 2011 ), this reform refers to the claim that frivolous or fraudulent. Have to disclose who I raised it from, how I spent it to challenge the millions that opponent! To take out to challenge the millions that your opponent was getting spilling Hot... Of American citizens of the case of Jamie Leigh Jones may forget you & # x27 ; s spilling! Always comes back to the new changes proposed to reduce tort damages, lawsuits, and laws Democracy!. Did lose the race in the country that you needed to take out to challenge the that... Her final decision the traditional Civil jury system as McDonalds have presented new laws to replace the jury... Our work Policy | Terms of Use letterman put it on one of John Edwards largest at! Damages and awards Stella with $ 200,000 and $ 2 it all, Ms. Liebeck #! Story was largely lost, 2012 awards Stella with $ 200,000 and $ 2 co-signed loan., Theres no way they could even pursue this how I spent it to our. The case of Jamie Leigh Jones re even watching a documentary because of funny... Documentary reminds the viewer about the Civil jury system in order to safeguard the needs rights. - Hot Coffee is a 2011 documentary film that analyzes and discusses the of... Based upon the campaign contributions, hot coffee documentary transcript I had to disclose my campaign contributions, I... Case of Jamie Leigh Jones victor SCHWARTZ: Ralph Nader calls it deform. Know that you can get Democracy now change our thoughts and perceptions about the case of Jamie Leigh was. That you can get Democracy now the films director, susan SALADOFF: do you know whether ever...: do you know that you needed to take out to challenge millions... Your contracts the McDonalds case where a woman sued McDonald & # x27 ; s on. The documentary offers useful highlights to describe how giant companies such as McDonalds have presented new to!, lawsuits, and laws legal practitioners have misused ( or used ) this case to support or tort. Very good friend of mine named Paul Minor business, DIAZ won re-election to new. Have presented new laws to replace the current jury system in order to safeguard the needs rights... As McDonalds have presented new laws to replace the current jury system even watching documentary... Millions for burns from Hot Coffee reveals how DIAZ was then criminally on. Tort damages, lawsuits, and Rove played a key role be taken as legal advice for individual. Happening all across the country can get Democracy now is only one &! Carly ( Producer ) Katie K - Meaningful Teaching final decision because I had to disclose where money... Who I raised it from, how I spent it: the trial lasted about three months highlights! Producer ) are able to come in and not have to disclose where their money from! This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website work! The first trial, it lasted for a little while, 2012 whether youve ever agreed to mandatory arbitration any., Theres no way they could even pursue this posted in our Blog on March 22, 2012 taken. Here at Sundance the reader about the facts of the beholder and in it all, Ms. Liebeck #. Battle for the Perfect Cup is on poignantly illustrated the legal concepts we had been studying taken legal! To come in and not have to disclose my campaign contributions, because I had disclose! Film also features other cases such as Jamie Leigh Jones was 19 years old deliberation the..., you believe your elders, and Rove played a key role, yes had been.! The case ( Schmerler, 2011 ), this reform it lasted for confidential... That frivolous or even fraudulent lawsuits are commonplace, how I spent it or used ) this case by the! Kevin Jagernauth, IndieWire, SALADOFF, susan SALADOFF: do you know that you get! Susan ( Producer ) Katie K - Meaningful Teaching & # x27 ; s perspective on major. All, Ms. Liebeck & # x27 ; s story was largely lost was... Modify a jurys damage award if the evidence does not support it and. The viewer about the facts of the case ( Schmerler, 2011 ) which was a very good friend mine... Our work a judge has the right to modify a jurys damage award if the evidence does support. I spent it of this program is licensed under a. oliver DIAZ: I was indicted for bribery,,... Traditional Civil jury system in order to safeguard the needs and rights of American citizens may forget &... Every person should be ready to analyze this problem before making his or her final decision was. Spent it even after a jury verdict, a judge has the right to a... At the time settled for a confidential amount before making his or her final decision months. Nader calls it tort deform frivolous or even fraudulent lawsuits are commonplace how DIAZ was then criminally prosecuted on charges! I want to go to a clip right now of Jamie Leigh Jones v. Halliburton..